Executive Board releases resolution on Membership Guidelines

(Mennonite Church USA)—Mennonite Church USA’s Executive Board (EB) is presenting a resolution on the status of Mennonite Church USA’s Membership Guidelines for consideration by the Delegate Assembly at convention in Kansas City, Missouri, from June 30 to July 5.

In the background to the resolution, the board wrote, “Our interactions show that the church is divided on understandings of human sexuality and same-sex marriage. That is why we also support the resolution calling for grace, love and forbearance in the midst of our differences. We think it best to restate our commitment to the agreements made by delegates in 2001, while exercising Christian forbearance with those who differ in their understanding and application of those agreements.”

The board drafted this resolution as part of its 2013 commitment to allow delegates to address the substance of the Membership Guidelines, and also to clarify the implications of the Resolution on Forbearance developed by Chicago Community Mennonite Church, North Baltimore (Maryland) Mennonite Church and Reba Place Church in Evanston, Illinois.

“The board is supportive of the resolution on forbearance but felt like there was a need to describe our understanding of what forbearance means,” said Patricia Shelly of North Newton, Kansas, moderator-elect. “We know we are living with different interpretations of what it means to follow Jesus, and we have to give some latitude for that. At the same time, forbearance doesn’t mean that we suspend all the agreements we’ve made in the past about how we will work together.”

Specific actions included in the resolution are:

  • A recommitment to the Membership Guidelines and the Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective as the “guiding documents” for questions regarding membership and same-sex relationships.
  • A commitment not to reexamine the Membership Guidelines again for four years.
  • An assumption that area conferences will grant ministerial credentials in keeping with the newly developed Mennonite Church USA polity manual, A Shared Understanding of Church Leadership, as interpreted in their contexts. This manual includes the statement, “Pastors holding credentials in a conference of Mennonite Church USA may not perform a same-sex covenant ceremony.”
  • A call to the Constituency Leaders Council (CLC) to exercise its role as “elders” for Mennonite Church USA. The resolution states, “We also call on the CLC to exercise mutual accountability by engaging in conference-to-conference peer review when area conferences make decisions that are not aligned with the documents named above, and to make recommendations to the Executive Board if necessary.”
  • A commitment to “… join hands for the work that binds us together — proclaiming Jesus’ gospel of peace, evangelizing the world and growing as missional Mennonite communities.”

EB members wrote a first draft of the resolution at their April meeting in Kansas City and tested the content of the resolution with CLC members.

“Undergirding this resolution is a sense that, in spite of our disagreements, we have other things that we want to do together,” said Shelly. “We want to focus in a new way on the common mission we feel a passion and calling for.”

The full text of the resolution is available online.

Pastoral letter and other resolutions

On April 30, the Executive Board sent a pastoral letter to all delegates outlining EB members’ hopes for the Delegate Assembly this summer. The letter states, “We write in a spirit of commitment, love and vision: We have been given a holy calling: to maintain the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace. We are committed to bear witness to the abundant life God offers to all who confess faith in Jesus Christ. … We are committed to helping each congregation become all that God intends for their life and witness.”

The full text of letter is available online.

During their April meeting, EB members also processed four resolutions affirmed by the CLC at their March 26–28 meeting in North Newton, Kansas:

  • The Forbearance in the Midst of Differences Resolution observes that there is no consensus within Mennonite Church USA about how LGBTQ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer) persons are included in the life of the church, and states, “We call on all those in Mennonite Church USA to offer grace, love and forbearance toward conferences, congregations and pastors in our body who, in different ways, seek to be faithful to our Lord Jesus Christ on matters related to same-sex covenanted unions.”
  • The Faithful Witness Amid Endless War Resolution calls for a recommitment to the way of peace and a rejection of mechanized (drone) warfare technologies.
  • The Churchwide Statement on Sexual Abuse mourns the ways in which sexual violence has been present within Mennonite Church USA and offers several concrete commitments and steps to prevent future abuse.
  • The Israel-Palestine Resolution offers support for continued Mennonite learning tours to the region as well as a commitment to the ongoing work for “just peace” in the region.

The full text of these resolutions, as well as the Delegate Assembly agenda, is available online.

The next meeting of the EB will take place on June 30 at the Crowne Plaza Hotel in Kansas City, Missouri.


—Mennonite Church USA staff

Official comments policy for users of Mennonite Church USA’s websites and other social networking tools. We reserve the right to remove any comment that violates this policy.

  • The purpose of comments is to engage in constructive dialogue.
  • Please provide your own full name.
  • Be respectful. If you’re offering criticism, focus on others’ ideas — not their motives, person, character or faith. Consider the log in your own eye before pressing ‘Enter.’

Comments are moderated. Comments with any content that is deemed obscene, libelous, defamatory or hateful toward an individual or group will not be approved. Comments will remain open for 10 days.

7 thoughts on “Executive Board releases resolution on Membership Guidelines

  1. How can we proclaim “Jesus gospel of peace” when we continue to practice spiritual and emotional abuse toward our LGBTQ brothers and sisters?

  2. Valerie, your question explains the route of our problem. We have made peace to be the judge of everything we are to think and do. Peace is only one aspect of the gospel, not the gospel itself. Neither is peace the primary attribute of God, for God does not have a primary attribute. We need to get back to a Christology based on the entire Word of God.

  3. To me it is just plain a paradox. Calling for forbearance and then stipulating on the very subject the forbearance is to be about, there has to be strict adherence to the membership guidelines under the polity that there will be strict discipline of anyone not following the membership guidelines. Where is the forbearance in such a restrictive resolution.

  4. I deeply appreciate all who have worked countless hours on this resolution, and wholeheartedly support it.

  5. So grateful for your time-consuming, thoughtful work, and leadership that is dealing with the core of Mennonite Church USA concerns.

  6. The definition of forbearance includes “the action of refraining from exercising a legal right, especially enforcing the payment of a debt.” It’s about exercising patient self-control; restraint and tolerance. Not seeing it in the resolution’s restating of the “rules and consequences” of interpreting them differently. Perhaps those days when our faith ancestors utilized a moveable flexible tent (tabernacle) weren’t that bad! Could it be the magnificent stones of the institutional church are about to be thrown down?

  7. For a huge part of what remains of Mennonite Church USA, this entire issue is simply dead and gone. The proposed resolution is completely out of touch with that reality. Those who have set this issue aside have moved on and will, rightly, ignore conversations about their status in the church. Change is bumpy. We are bumping. Change has already happened.

Comments are closed.