A sincere thank you

Ervin Stutzman is executive director of Mennonite Church USAErvin Stutzman is executive director of Mennonite Church USA

As a convener of the Discernment Group, I read, along with many of you, “The failure to bind and loose” (January 2015 The Mennonite) and the much longer “’Defanging the Beast,’: Mennonite responses to John Howard Yoder’s Sexual Abuse” (January 2015, Mennonite Quarterly Review ). Historian Rachel Waltner Goossen has done the church a profound service. She chronicled the history of John Howard Yoder’s “sexual experiment,” and the church’s failure to effectively intervene to halt his violation of dozens of women in many places around the world. The article is like bitter medicine—an unpleasant dose of reality. I hope in time it can serve as a tonic to restore a measure of health and vitality to our church. Thank you Rachel for your careful and courageous work. I offer a special word of thanks to John Roth, the editor of MQR, who has demonstrated with professional grace how scholarship can serve the church by devoting the entire January 2015 issue of MQR to discussion about the church’s relationship to power, response to sexual abuse, and healing for victims.


Nine authors wrote MQR articles which provide helpful insight and guidance to congregational leaders. Because many readers of this blog may not have ready access to the MQR, I name here the articles and authors I especially hope to entice you to read:

  • “Sexual Abuse by Church Leaders and Healing for Victims,” by Carolyn Holderread Heggen
  • “Congregational Responses to Abuse and Trauma: The Persistent Hope of Shalom” by Rebecca Slough
  • “Naming the Pain, Seeking the Light: The Mennonite Church’s Response to Sexual Abuse” by Linda Gehman Peachey
  • “Seventy Times Seven: Abuse and the Frustratingly Extravagant Call To Forgive” by Gayle Gerber Koontz


Each of these articles provides a different window for understanding the damage of abuse, and the church’s essential role to accompany victims on a journey of healing. I am particularly grateful for these women’s work to provide both a theology and practical guidance to undergird our accompaniment of persons who have suffered abuse.


I also offer my deeply-felt appreciation for Barbra Graber, Ruth Krall, Carolyn Holderread Heggen, Martha Smith Good and others who over many long years tenaciously persisted in their courageous efforts to raise awareness about the horrible pain and damage unleashed by sexual abuse in our faith communities. I am grateful for their efforts to expose the wrongs inflicted on so many and also to point us toward healing for survivors and ways to prevent future abuse.


The Discernment Group’s concern goes well beyond initiating the documentation of the sexual abuse perpetrated by Yoder and the church’s response to that abuse. Our strong hope is to rally the church to take additional measures to prevent further sexual abuse in our faith communities. In that vein, we have drafted a statement on sexual abuse to be considered by the delegate assembly at Kansas City 2015. It is now in the hands of the Resolutions Committee, who will take it to the next steps of the adoption process.


We also are planning ways to invite institutions and individuals to contribute to a fund to recompense at least in small measure some of the material costs women undertook on their road to healing, and to prevent future abuse. We will invite an offering designated for this purpose at the Kansas City 2015 convention. While such a fund will be a sorely inadequate acknowledgement of the hurt that many have experienced, we believe it is an important step for our church to take. We believe many persons will welcome an opportunity to contribute to the healing and prevention of sexual abuse.


Finally, we have arranged for a Worship Service of Lament and Hope to be held at the Kansas City convention. It will be a time to lament the reality of sexual abuse among us, and to seek for God’s healing and hope in the midst of the harm that so many have experienced. Mary Lehman Yoder of Goshen, Indiana is leading the team which is planning the service.


May God grant us the courage and the grace to face the realities of what happened among us in the past. May we commit ourselves anew to a future filled with God’s healing and hope.

Official comments policy for users of Mennonite Church USA’s websites and other social networking tools. We reserve the right to remove any comment that violates this policy.

  • The purpose of comments is to engage in constructive dialogue.
  • Please provide your own full name.
  • Be respectful. If you’re offering criticism, focus on others’ ideas — not their motives, person, character or faith. Consider the log in your own eye before pressing ‘Enter.’

Comments are moderated. Comments with any content that is deemed obscene, libelous, defamatory or hateful toward an individual or group will not be approved. Comments will remain open for 10 days.

2 thoughts on “A sincere thank you

  1. Thank you Ervin for this offer of thanks and gratitude. Thank you also for the courageous decisions you and the Yoder Discernment Group have made to get us to this day. It is indeed bitter medicine but the kind that can lead toward a more vibrant, healthy church.

  2. Thank you and all those courageous and persevering women and men who have labored so long to bring the truth to light.This includes, above all, those women dishonored by Yoder–and by other church leaders, now and in the past. This includes also brave women likeRuth Krall, whose monumental work deserves to be better known, as well as all the others, mostly women leaders, psychologists, teachers who were not believed for so long. I have been concerned about the larger issue of abuse of power, and sexual abuse of women, for over 40 years: as a college teacher of Women’s history/Women’s Studies since 1972 ( retired);for over 16 years, as a child protection social worker; and as a convert to the Mennonite church since the late 1960’s There is an irony here: I was drawn to Mennonites because the men seemed better and finer than other men I’d known. And,surely,most of them are fine and good. Yet, from the first year I lived and traveled among Mennonite communities across this country, I began to hear personalstories of Mennonite women– and girls–and boys- mistreated and abused by Mennonite men–their pastors, leaders, and even relatives. This dates back to the late 1960’s.
    These stories, from women,men, andyoung people whom I knew and cherished, and who, for some reason, trusted me– were totally unsolicited by me. I had not yet begun my work in Women’s Studies. I never shared their stories with anyone, and never turned to any woman leader to help me make sense of them–much less to offer assistance to any of these women. Nor did I ever write of these things. It did drive me, though, to make teaching women’s history my vocation.Only now, writing this, do I realize that my long silence was also a betrayal. For any of those who told me their stories long ago, and are reading this now,
    I hope you will forgive me for that long silence.

Comments are closed.